
raises both hands and looks toward the sky during a match, appearing to react to a
moment of play with distress. Photo by Jayden Blythe.
Week 18 of the NFL season, depending on the team you support, is an interesting week. If your team has clinched a playoff spot, the last game is nearly pointless. For some, it could be a game to qualify for the playoffs. For other fans, it’s the end of a dreadful season. Your team is 3-13, and you’re almost hoping for a loss to make your draft pick better.
While no fans like to watch their team lose, many fans would rather be 3-14 than 7-10. Neither team has done well enough to make the playoffs, but the poorer record means you get a better draft pick. So, why would you not want to lose more?
This concept would be baffling to the average English Premier League fan in England, wanting your team to lose. Why is that the case? The Premier League has a vastly different structure to the American leagues such as the NBA, NFL or MLB.
What’s different? First, EPL does not have a playoff. If you finish first in the league, you win the championship. Teams who finish in the top 4 earn the privilege to play in the Champions League the following season, a tournament where the best teams in the world do battle.
Easily the most intriguing factor of the Premier League is the structure of English Soccer (or Football, as it is called there), “The English Football Pyramid.” In England, there are 7 levels of soccer, Premier League, EFL Championship, EFL League One and Two, National League, and National League North and South. Beyond these levels, there are thousands of clubs at the Grassroots level.
The EFL Championship is very comparable to the NBA’s G-League, guys who may be just below that top level. The lowest level of English football would be comparable to a team you might find at your local gym.
So why does England have all these leagues? What makes it different from the lower leagues America has? One exhilarating concept, relegation and promotion. The same way the top 4 Premier League clubs qualify for the champions league, the bottom 3 clubs face relegation. They get demoted from the Premier League to the EFL Championship. They play a full year in the league below the one they were in last season and must place top 8 and win a playoff to gain their spot back. This trickles down all 7 leagues in the pyramid.
Wild, huh? Imagine your NBA team doing so bad they got sent to the G-League. While a crazy concept, I personally think this would be perfect in America, The Promotion-Relegation system keeps fans from getting bored and tired of the season, the same way you might feel watching your NFL team lose their 11th game of the season.
This system makes a random game at the end of the year feel like the playoffs. You need to win, or your team gets demoted into the league below for a year minimum.
Last season, Premier League club Tottenham Hotspur, regarded as a top club in Europe, had an absolutely horrific season. They looked into the eyes of Relegation all year, battling with West Ham United to try to keep their spot in the league.
It all came down to one final game, Spurs vs. Everton. If the Spurs win, they stay in the Premier League. If they lose and West Ham wins, they’d be relegated for the first time since 1976. Spurs beat Everton 1-0 and all-over south London, the supporters were all smiles. Their club finished the year with 10 wins in 38 games and they were…happy? Not the same way a Browns fan feels after the 3rd losing season in a row.
Former Team USA’s manager Mauricio Pochettino, who recently returned to the Premier League to coach Manchester United, spoke on the use of the Promotion-Relegation system in America.
“If you start in MLS and you haven’t won a game in three months and you’re at the bottom, what’s the consequence if there’s no promotion or relegation, no international competition?” he said. “American sports reward losers! But soccer is different: if you reward those who don’t win… If you don’t have goals, you don’t fight. If I lose, what happens? Nothing. They just fire the coach.”
This quote resonates heavily in the NFL. The Titans, Browns, Jets, and other teams who have found little success over a long period go through this same carousel of firing and re-hiring coaches. Quarterback after quarterback, losing year after losing year, and yet no consequence.
For the players and coaches, there is the threat of losing your job, but what of the owners? I’m sure it would make Jets owner Woody Johnson try a bit harder if he had the threat of being demoted into the XFL in his mind.
For the American leagues to implement this system, a lot of things would have to change, most notably the draft. Does it stay the same through this process, or should it change? I’m not sure you’d want the NFL’s #1 overall pick to play in the XFL.
Even though it would be a challenging process, I have no doubt that something like this would help American sports for the better. The fans with bad teams deserve to feel the need to root for their teams, even if they are having a bad year.
